I had the most success on Hinge. 6 months or so now with a thick girl. I don't mind hefty if there's a shape to it. Also, I'm mid 40's. Whether or not I can stand to hang out with someone slightly edges out appearance. I ain't got time for dummies.
Tinder was a total waste. No idea why. Matches never went anywhere.
Bumble was mildly successful. Ghosted a chick or two, matched but didn't pursue many others.
OKC was wack. Lots of matches, but many from Africa and other ghetto countries. Same with Match.
Met a high-falutin jewess on eharmony. Several dates, lots of passion, but never sealed the deal. She had a very busy social life and youngish kids. Not my thing. Speaking of which, 35-45 years old and have 6-12 year old kids? Nah, dawg. I'm done with that.
POF is full of Philipinas, bots and skanks.
I think I fucked around on a couple other apps but I can't recall.